| A is for anyone who's not afraid to die | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| All hail the power of Jesus' name, Let angels prostrate fall | John J. Overholt (Author (chorus)) | English | 2 |
| Amidst us our Beloved stands | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| And must I be to judgment brought | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Angels we have heard on high | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Another week with all its cares hath flown | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Awake, thou Spirit of the martyrs | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Baptized into our Savior's death | John J. Overholt (Adapter) | English | 1 |
| Behold, the Master passeth by! | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Behold the Savior of mankind | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Blessing to God, the Father ever blest | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| Blest feast of love divine | John J. Overholt (Author (refrain)) | English | 1 |
| Church of God, thou spotless virgin | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Climb up your golden height | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| Come, great God, thy people hear | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 2 |
| Come, let our souls adore the Lord | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Come, newborn souls, love's grace display | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| Come, and let us sweetly join | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Come, Savior, Jesus, from above | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Come, Thou Almighty King, Help us Thy name to sing | Compiler (Alterer (st. 3)) | English | 1 |
| Come, Thy presence manifesting | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| Come unto me, saith God's own Son | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Come, ye that love the Savior's name | John J. Overholt (Adapter) | English | 1 |
| Come, your hearts and voices raising (Overholt) | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| Come, Zion's daughters, come, rejoice | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Creator of the universe, We lift our minds | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Dear Lord, amid the throng that pressed | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Did Christ o'er sinners weep? | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Dona nobis pacem, pacem (Canon) | John J. Overholt (English text) | Latin | 1 |
| Draw nigh, O Lord, and on us shine | Compiler (Alterer) | | 1 |
| Everybody ought to know, Everybody ought to know | John J. Overholt (Arranger) | English | 1 |
| Everything's alright in my Father's house | Compiler (Arranger) | English | 1 |
| Father, bless our school today | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Father eternal, great God of creation | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| Father, in whom we live | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Father of spirits, whose divine control | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Father, we thank Thee, Father, we thank Thee (Overholt) | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| For a blest today | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| For the bread and for the wine | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Forward, flock of Jesus | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Foundation true, art Thou, O Lord | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Fountain of knowledge, living breath | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Glorious kingdom of our God | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| God, of truth and light Creator | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| God, our Father, send revival | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| God the All-terrible! King, who ordainest | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| God will His righteous judgment mete | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Gracious Lord, we wait on thee | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Great Ruler of the earth and skies | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Great Shepherd of the church on earth | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | | 2 |
| Hallelujah, hallelujah, hallelujah … He is coming soon | John J. Overholt (Arranger) | English, German | 1 |
| Hark! the voice of love and mercy | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Have you counted the cost | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | | 1 |
| Have you found the great Physician, Jesus Christ of Galilee | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| Have you heard about the stone | Compiler (Arranger) | English | 1 |
| He that believes and is baptized | John J. Overholt (Compositer) | English | 1 |
| Help us, O Lord, Thy yoke to wear | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Here in the Name of Christ our Lord | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Holy and reverend is the name | John J. Overholt (Adapter) | English | 1 |
| I am unworthy to suffer with thee | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| I had so many sins and He took them all away | Compiler (Arranger) | English | 1 |
| I opened my heart to the Word divine | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| I will abide in thy dwelling place forever | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| I will delight in singing | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| I will press on to perfection | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| In all thy glorious ways, O God | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| In Christ is brotherhood alone | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| In Christ my Saviour's wounds secure | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| In memory of the Savior's love | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 2 |
| In Thee is gladness in every sadness | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Into thy gracious hands I fall | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| It is finished, all the pain | John J. Overholt (Author (stanza 4)) | English | 1 |
| Jesus can never fail, never fail, never fail | Compiler (Arranger) | English | 1 |
| Jesus, for thy mercy's sake | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Jesus, Jesus, Life, the fountain | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Jesus, joy of living | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Jesus, Lord from heaven | John J. Overholt (Author) | | 1 |
| To the name that brings salvation | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Jesus, the Christ, the Son of God | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Jesus, Thou soul of all our joys | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Leader of faithful souls, and Guide | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Let the saints new anthems raise | Compiler (Alterer (stanza 1)) | English | 1 |
| Let the people praise thee, O God, O let them praise thee! | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| Light of life, seraphic fire | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Live in me Lord Jesus | John J. Overholt (Author (stanza 3)) | | 1 |
| Lo! God is here: let us adore | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Lo! golden light rekindles day | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Lo, wisdom crieth in the streets | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Look to the God of heaven above for guidelines every day | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| God give us Christian homes | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Lord God! to Thee be blessing | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Lord, in the fullness of my might, I would for Thee be strong | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Lord Jesus, I love Thee , My Lord, I Thee confess | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| Lord of our life, and God of our salvation | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Lord of the harvest, meet this hour | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Lord of the living harvest | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| By Thy blessed word obeying, Lord | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Lord, we would not dishonor Thee | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| My faith has found a resting place, from guilt my soul is freed | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| My God, how wonderful Thou art | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| My God, where shall I wend my flight? | Compiler (Alterer (stanzas 8 & 11)) | English | 1 |
| My Savior and my Lord, let our lips now acclaim Thee | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| My soul complete in Jesus stands | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Now be praise unto our God | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| Now the busy week is done | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O come, all ye children, O come, one and all (Overholt) | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O come, let us worship before our great Lord | John J. Overholt (Author) | | 1 |
| I thirst, Thou wounded Lamb of God | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O come to Mount Zion, the mount of the Lord | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O come today to the fountain, Drawn from Immanuel's veins | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| O come ye children of men mortal | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| O God and Father, thee we bless | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 6 |
| O God, do thou sustain me | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| O God of wondrous grace and glory | John J. Overholt (Compositer, Arranger) | English | 1 |
| O God, to thee I lift my joyful voice | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| O God, what offering shall I give | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O Gott, Vater, wir loben dich | John J. Overholt (Translator) | German | 1 |
| O holy, holy, holy Lord! Thou God of hosts, by all adored! | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O lift thy hands on high! | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O Lord of life, wherever they be | John J. Overholt (Alterer (stanzas 1-3)) | English | 1 |
| O Lord of hosts, all heaven possessing | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O Love that casts out fear, O Love that casts out sin | John J. Overholt (Composite, Arranger) | English | 2 |
| O brother man, fold to thy heart thy brother | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O our God, to Thee we render Thanks for bounties Thou hast given | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| O sinners, what will you do | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| O Son of God, all loves excelling | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| O Son of God, we wait for Thee, We long for Thine appearing (Seiss) | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| O soul, do not delay | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| O that a thousand tongues I'd treasure | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| O Thou Almighty Lord and God | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| O Thou, from Whom all goodness flows | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Of the Father's heart begotten Ere the world from chaos rose | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| ¡Oh Dios, a ti te elevo mi canción! | John J. Overholt (Author) | Spanish | 1 |
| On our way rejoicing, as we homeward move | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Once in a lonely manger, hundreds of years ago | John J. Overholt (Arranged by) | English | 1 |
| Pardon me, O my God | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| Pilgrim, awake! to newborn life | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Pilgrim, seek not yet repose | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | | 2 |
| Praise the Lord, ye heavens adore Him | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Rejoice! be glad exceedingly (Verheucht nu en weest verblijt) | John J. Overholt (Versifier) | Dutch, English | 1 |
| Rise, my soul, to watch and pray, From thy sleep awake thee (Winkworth) | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Savior, again to Thy dear name we raise (Ellerton) | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Say now, ye lovely social band | John J. Overholt (Author (stanza 3)) | English | 1 |
| Shepherd of souls, refresh and bless | John J. Overholt (Author (stanza 5)) | English | 1 |
| Stand up, and bless the Lord Ye people of His choice | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Stand up, my soul, shake off thy fears | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 2 |
| Standing forth on life's rough way | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Stay, Thou insulted Spirit, stay | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Sun of Righteousness, arise! Dispel darkness from our eyes | John J. Overholt (Compositer) | English | 2 |
| Teach me to do the thing that pleaseth Thee | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| The Church of God a kingdom is | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| The Father we will ever praise | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ (Overholt) | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| The heavens are lowering overcast | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| "The Lord is risen indeed;" And are the tidings true? | John J. Overholt (Author (st. 5)) | English | 1 |
| The Lord, our God, alone is strong | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| The Lord's my shepherd, I'll not want; He makes me down to lie (Rous) | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| The church of God believes it right | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Thee will I love, my Lord, my God | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| There are two ways in this, our day | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| They come from the east and west, they come from the lands afar | John J. Overholt (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Thou to Whom the sick and dying | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Through night and day Thy glory | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| To our Father, true and kind | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| 'Twas on that night, when doomed to know | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Unto Thy church, Thy body, Lord | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| We are pilgrims on the earth reconciled by Jesus' blood | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| We now show forth the dying of our Lord | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| We'll walk in the light, beautiful light, Dwelling in heaven in pure rainment white | John J. Overholt (Author) | English | 1 |
| When Christ beheld, in sinful [sin's dark] night | John J. Overholt (Author (stanza 3)) | English | 1 |
| When Christ with His true teaching came | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| When I behold the risen Lord | Compiler (Alterer) | | 1 |
| When saints of God in danger stood | Compiler (Alterer (chorus)) | English | 1 |
| Who Christ will follow now, newborn | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Who shall the Lord's elect condemn? | Compiler (Alterer) | English | 1 |
| Wonderful redemption full and free | John J. Overholt (Translator) | English | 1 |
| Would you win men's souls to God | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| Rise again, ye lion hearted | John J. Overholt (Recaster) | English | 1 |
| Ye must be born again, salvation to obtain | John J. Overholt (Author) | | 1 |
| You Christian brothers, together (Ghy Christen broeders te samen) | John J. Overholt (Versifier) | Dutch, English | 1 |
| You weary pilgrims roaming here | Compiler (Alterer) | | 1 |